
ArmInfo. A number of journalistic organizations have demanded that the Ministry of Justice of Armenia withdraw the draft law "On Making Additions and Amendments to the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia," which revises the amounts of monetary compensation for insult and defamation.
As the organizations reminded, under the draft, in addition to the already established maximum compensation amounts of 3 million drams (about $8.3 thousand) for insult and 6 million drams (about $16.6 thousand) for defamation, it is also proposed to establish a minimum threshold of 1 million (about $2.77 thousand) and 2 million drams (about $5.5 thousand), respectively. "In other words, when filing such lawsuits, plaintiffs will not be able to demand, and courts will not have the right to award, compensation below the specified minimum amounts. The proposed changes and additions are causing serious concern, especially among journalists and mass media outlets, since the aforementioned article of the Civil Code primarily concerns the liability of persons operating in the media sector," says a statement received by ArmInfo.
It further notes that the published draft law nullifies the positive practice whereby, when considering cases of insult and defamation, courts not only rejected claims for the maximum compensation amounts, but also awarded amounts dozens of times lower than those claimed. Journalistic organizations also drew attention to the fact that, according to data from many years of monitoring court cases against mass media outlets and journalists, in cases where courts award, for example, compensation of 200-300 thousand drams for insult or defamation, plaintiffs generally do not appeal this part of the court decisions. "This raises the question: why is the state interfering in an issue that does not require such interference and giving the institution of compensation elements of liability characteristic of criminal law?" the statement further says.
In this regard, attention is drawn to the fact that there are frequent cases when politicians, high-ranking officials and other public figures perceive even objective criticism as insult or defamation and turn to the courts in order to "punish" mass media outlets. Moreover, as the journalistic organizations noted, such intentions are being pursued in conditions where an independent judicial system has not yet been formed and individual judges issue decisions with a political subtext. "Based on the above, we demand that the Ministry of Justice withdraw this draft law on making changes and additions to the Civil Code of Armenia and initiate open professional discussions with the participation of media representatives regarding the validity of the document’s very concept and the need to tighten liability for insult and defamation. At the same time, send the draft law to the Council of Europe and other international organizations for expert review and an opinion on its compliance with European standards," the journalistic organizations concluded.
The statement was signed by: the Committee to Protect Freedom of Speech, Yerevan Press Club, Media Initiatives Center, Freedom of Information Center, Institute for War and Peace Reporting - Armenia, "Asparez" Journalists’ Club, Public Journalism Club, the public organization "Journalists for the Future," and the NGO "Journalists for Human Rights."
It should be recalled that, according to the draft law presented on the e-draft.am platform, compensation for insult is proposed to be set at 1 to 3 million drams (about $2.77 thousand - $8.3 thousand), for defamation at 2 to 6 million drams (about $5.5 thousand- $16.6 thousand), for certain violations of fundamental rights at 1 to 4 million drams (about $2.8 thousand- $11 thousand), for violation of the right to life at 3 to 8 million drams, and for torture at 4 million drams (no upper limit is stipulated - Ed.). Discussions on the draft will continue until December 1.